Home » Interesting Questions » Possibility of a nuclear fusion reactor

Possibility of a nuclear fusion reactor

JED asks: ” Why hasn’t anyone built a nuclear fusion reactor using polodial (?) magnetic fields?

When 2 parallel wires have current running in the same direction, they attract each other

When those same 2 wires have current running in opposite directions, they repel each other

Why hasnt anyone built one where positively ionised deuterium is forced through to doughnut shaped apparatus that contains ionised hydrogen travelling in the opposite direction

This should create a strong repulsion between the ionised deuterium in the centre and the ionised hydrogen in the containment field apparatus (like a coiled up phone cord made into a doughnut shape)

With enough hydrogen running through the containment field apparatus at a high enough speed (relativistic most likely), there would be sufficient force compressing the ions to cause them to fuse, if the fuel was forced through at a rate of 0.8 – 1 gram per second with an average ion speed between 200,000,000 m/s and 300,000,000 m/s

I know about Zpinch instability, but the way the reactor is designed (it also needs a powerful current travelling in the same direction as the fuel, this will induce it to accelerate more, and will allow energy extraction from the fused ions passing out of the pinch point

The size of the reactor depends on the difficulty of containing hydrogen ions moving at relativistic speeds

It is meant to bypass the disadvantages of a Z-pinch reactor (by having a containment field generated by heavy, moving ions, through a path of no resistance

the reactor vessel would have to be a tube, as small as possible while still able to keep a vacuum and keep the fuel path clear, the containment field apparatus would also be made of tubes, designed to contain the ions and direct them around the pinch point with the highest possible current

my main question is
“would it work?(pretty much the same as “why hasn’t anyone built one yet?”)” and
“will you give me credit for design/concept if you decide to build it?” (not so much for the money for the actual reactor, but the scientific recognition so I can test out my other ideas and be taken seriously)

Answer: (I am not answering; Let the visitors respond)


  1. Creating the required conditions for fusion on Earth are very difficult. For nuclear weapons, some of the energy released by an atomic bomb is used to compress and heat a fusion fuel to the point of “ignition”. At this point, the energy released in the fusion reactions is enough to maintain the reaction. Fusion-based nuclear power experiments attempt to create similar conditions using less dramatic means, although to date these experiments have failed to maintain conditions needed for ignition long enough for fusion to be a viable commercial power source.

    The concept is great, I am compelled to say, but having a nuclear reactor that produces approx. 17.59 MeV per 2H and 3H fusing, without the ability to moderate the reaction is suicide.

  2. Thanks for the info; after hearing so much about the EU and the Z pinch, I was wondering why we slid to a stop at the Z pinch. So why is there no interest in seeing a magnetic field compress in another way than a zzz?
    It seems that the nova on Sol’s doorstep did so. And may have left a bit of neutron matter behind and this is what is incurring periodically in Sol’s system. Additionally, if the magnetic wrap left Sol’s primary twin a bit of neutron rock, it is possible that O Manuel’s Iron Sun may be possible. If after compressing the primary twin to nova and then to neutron, it then wrapped Sol and had achieved a small neutron core before the power dropped. It would explain the puzzle of the start/stop seen in cosmic novas, and it would take care of the primary criticism of Iron Sun, the lack of this past Sol’s system.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Hits so far @ AskPhysics

  • 2,274,296 hits

You may also be interested in

Subscribe to AskPhysics via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 4,339 other subscribers

July 2021

Learn Self Defence Techniques online

%d bloggers like this: